Altruism, Ethics and Compassion

Altruism, Ethics and Compassion

This Dialogue will focus on the study of altruism and compassion in Western science. The participants will address these topics from a highly multi-disciplinary perspective since altruism and compassion are clearly significant for both the social and life sciences. A historical perspective on the role of compassion in science and the bias in the study of negative rather positive psychological states in the behavioral sciences will first be considered. The role of altruism in evolutionary biology will be examined and its relevance to understanding human motivation will be discussed. The characteristics that determine whether people help other people in need will be the focus of another presentation. A related topic, and one central to the contemporary world situation, concerns the conditions that give rise to genocidal violence. The ingredients that are essential to positive socialization and the cultivation of altruism and compassion in children will also be examined. Finally, what is the relevance of altruistic motives to economic behavior? There is a class of economic problems in which selfish motives, assumed by most economics to underlie all significant economic behavior, are found to be self defeating. This meeting will bring together scholars in psychology, philosophy, economics and the history of science. The discussion each day will focus on relations between Western and Tibetan Buddhist understanding of concepts that are central to both traditions. 

Dialogue Sessions

Science and Compassion – Conceiving the Relationship (Part I)

Anne Harrington discusses a potential dialogue between Tibetan Buddhism and Western science, exploring the historical imbalance in Western sciences’ attention to violent behavior versus loving emotions, examining the practices of Buddhism and science in cultivating compassion, questioning the presumed moral elevation of scientific rationality, and investigating the connection between scientific theories of human nature and the practical role of science in society.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Science and Compassion – Conceiving the Relationship (Part II)

Anne Harrington discusses a potential dialogue between Tibetan Buddhism and Western science, exploring the historical imbalance in Western sciences’ attention to violent behavior versus loving emotions, examining the practices of Buddhism and science in cultivating compassion, questioning the presumed moral elevation of scientific rationality, and investigating the connection between scientific theories of human nature and the practical role of science in society.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

How are Biological Evolution and Psychological Altruism Related?

Evolutionary biologists use the concepts of altruism and selfishness to describe the effects that a behavior has on an organism’s fitness–its ability to survive and reproduce. A mindless creature can be an evolutionary altruist, if it helps another individual at cost to itself.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Responsibility and Inclusive Caring in Altruistic Helping and Group Violence (Part I)

Ervin Staub’s discussion comprises three parts: the first examines research on helping behavior in emergencies, focusing on the factors influencing bystanders’ sense of responsibility and the inhibiting effect of social rules; the second analyzes the origins of genocidal violence, considering social, cultural, and psychological factors, as well as the role of bystanders; the third describes “positive socialization” in children through home and school environments, fostering values of altruism and the ability to oppose destructive group policies.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Responsibility and Inclusive Caring in Altruistic Helping and Group Violence (Part II)

Ervin Staub’s discussion comprises three parts: the first examines research on helping behavior in emergencies, focusing on the factors influencing bystanders’ sense of responsibility and the inhibiting effect of social rules; the second analyzes the origins of genocidal violence, considering social, cultural, and psychological factors, as well as the role of bystanders; the third describes “positive socialization” in children through home and school environments, fostering values of altruism and the ability to oppose destructive group policies.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Empathy-Related Emotional Responses, Altruism, and Their Socialization (Part I)

Psychologists have found that various empathy-related emotional responses such as sympathy and personal distress relate differently to the performance of prosocial behavior.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Empathy-Related Emotional Responses, Altruism, and Their Socialization (Part II)

Psychologists have found that various empathy-related emotional responses such as sympathy and personal distress relate differently to the performance of prosocial behavior.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Can Altruism Survive in Competitive Environments? (Part I)

According to many Western biologists and other behavioral scientists, competition has assured that narrow self-interest is the only important human motive. In this presentation, we will challenge this prevailing view by describing an important class of economic and social problems in which selfish motives turn out to be self-defeating. Drawing on evidence that reliable nonverbal signals of character exist, we will explain how cooperative predispositions might survive in – and, indeed, even be nurtured by – competitive environments.

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Can Altruism Survive in Competitive Environments? (Part II)

In evolutionary terms, altruists gain advantage by being able to identify, and interact selectively with, one another. Implicit in this view is the need to avoid interacting with opportunists. What does the Tibetan Buddhist tradition say about avoiding people of bad character?

Watch Session
  • Audio
  • Subtitles
  • Transcript
  • Video

Participants

Honorary Board Chair
  • His Holiness the Dalai Lama
Interpreters
  • Thupten Jinpa, PhD
  • Jose Ignacio Cabezon, PhD
Speakers and Panelists
  • His Holiness the 14th Dalai Lama
  • Richard J. Davidson, PhD
  • Nancy Eisenberg, PhD
  • Robert Frank, PhD
  • Anne Harrington, PhD
  • Elliott Sober, PhD
  • Ervin Staub, PhD